Wednesday, August 23, 2006

Burb magazine review of The Suburban Christian

Burb magazine, an excellent, thoughtful gateway to articles and links on all things suburban, has just posted a review of my book:

At the heart of many critiques of suburban life is a critique of the suburbs' soul--or the lack of one. So books like "The Suburban Christian" by Albert Hsu, an editor at Intervarsity Press, are more pertinent than its parochial title may suggest. Devout Christians are particularly out of sorts in the suburbs; the emphasis on prosperity and acquisitiveness is the opposite of the Christian ideal of service and sacrifice. But suburban values concern faithful and secular suburbanites alike. And Hsu, who grew up in Bloomington, Minn., has a native son's affection for malls and megachurches that moves him to look for real, and sometimes surprising solutions.

Hsu's respect for the suburbs sets him apart from other Christian takes on the burbs, like Dave Goetz's fizzy "Death By Suburb: How to Keep the Suburbs from Killing Your Soul," published earlier this year, which seemed to draw its moral situations from soap-opera suburbs. Hsu also distinguishes himself from heavy-hitting academic and media prognosticators by having a little, well, faith in the suburbs.

The suburbs, in Hsu's vision, ought to be more than neatly arranged nodes of convenience. "Instead of the job being the lead factor [in where you live], how about having community be the decisive factor. ... Choose your community, live there, work there, worship there and minister there." Hsu wants us to be intentional about where we live, and not abstractly. Investing ourselves in the physical place, in Hsu's vision, can be a route to spiritual investment. He is tempted by the idea of ditching single family homes, with their impractical land use and outsized mortgages, in favor of suburban-futurist ideas about "sixplexes," where one house holds six families with a common kitchen and living areas (New Urbanists: how's that for density?), or private homes surrounded by communal land.

Hsu presents the shortcomings of his own Christian community too, warning that megachurches—Christian mallls that entice suburban parishioners with shopping, entertainment and worship—risk becoming the culture they seek to change. Worried that suburban Christians are too comfortable, he wants them to turn back to the cities they have left to experience hardship and suffering and help heal it.

At times, Hsu allows the suburbs to stand for too many of the ills of our current culture, overemphasizing the racial and economic homogeneity or portraying materialism too strictly as a suburban phenomenon. And too much of the book is taken up with statistics and trends any newspaper reader (or pew denizen) will have already absorbed. Both these sins are available in nearly any current treatise on the suburbs. What you won't always find are Hsu's optimism and exhortation to positive action.


Craver Vii said...

"And too much of the book is taken up with statistics and trends any newspaper reader (or pew denizen) will have already absorbed."

"Denizen." That's a fun word. "Denizen." It has a pleasant sound, doesn't it? Anyway, this pew denizen appreciates the statistics, because it adds weight to the author's opinions. I love being able to quote some of these statistics to others and then point, with certainty, where they can be found in print. It adds weight to my opinions. No Burb, it is not a sin, but a virtue.

Anonymous said...

Dear Al, I picked up a copy of your book last weekend and just finished it this morning. I really enjoyed it and thought you did a great job discussing the impact that consumerism has had, not only on people in the suburbs, but on rural areas as well. I live in a rural area in north-central Iowa and many, if not most, of the people within my church are more than willing to run to Des Moines, or the Twin Cities or Rochester and really treat those areas as their backyard playgrounds.
On a side note, I am also a graduate of Minnesota Bible College (2002) and I enjoyed the comments you made about the school and the thinking of many of the churches of Christ/Christian churches in the state of Minnesota and the upper midwest. I agree completely.
Thanks again for the book -- as Paul MacAlister would say, "It was a good read."

Curt Gallmeyer